When is College Worth the Money?
Anna Lu
TL;DR: Evaluating college return on investment (ROI) has become essential for families as higher education has historically shifted from a subsidized public good into a private and career-minded individual investment. By measuring a school's actual net price against projected mid-career graduate earnings, families can look past brand prestige to find true financial value. This guide breaks down the historical evolution of the college debt crisis, key limitations standard ROI data often misses, and highlights top-performing, high-ROI institutions like the Georgia Institute of Technology, Northeastern University, Colorado School of Mines, and Carleton College.
When students build college lists, the prestige of a school is often less important than its ROI. College ROI, or return on investment, refers to how much money your student gains after graduation compared to what they initially pay for college. In other words, ROI takes a student's college tuition and expenses and measures it up against that student's projected earnings and career stability over the next few decades.
Families must look past the sticker price of a college and instead evaluate the net price (what families actually pay after scholarships and aid, and including expenses for things like housing, dining, supplies, et cetera) against the median mid-career salary of that college's graduates.
The crucial context: Why and when did ROI become so important?
ROI is a fairly new, modern metric in the higher education landscape. To better understand the development of ROI, it’s important to understand how the purpose and focus of a college education in the United States changed over time.
The first colleges in the United States—the nine colonial colleges, including Harvard, Yale, and Princeton—predated the Revolution and were almost exclusively to cultivate the wealthy elite into an educated clergy and leadership class. College was a luxury, and focused on instruction of theology and classical studies (e.g. Latin, philosophy, history), not economic mobility.
Then, in the mid- to late 1800s, land-grant universities like UC Berkeley and UIUC were founded on public land given to states by the federal government, on the condition that all money gained by states from selling that land to universities were then used to fund new colleges. Land-grant universities were instead required to teach more practicality-focused disciplines, such as agriculture, engineering, and military tactics. The focus of a college education shifted from the character and leadership cultivation of the wealthy elite to national development and industrialization for rural and working class citizens.
Fast forward to the mid-20th century: World War II had just ended, and Roosevelt signed the original GI Bill to help millions of returning veterans readjust to civilian lifestyles. Included in these benefits was tuition for four years’ worth of education, including at universities, which were suddenly flooded with middle-class veteran students. Suddenly, higher education was considered a public good, and was emphatically being funded by the government for the masses.
Then, in the late 20th century, Reagan rejected the idea that taxpayers should have to fund the public’s education, and proposed adding tuition to public colleges, thus critically reframing college from being a public good for the nation to being a private investment for the individual. Higher education became focused on training trade skills, meant to provide equipped workers to the growing corporate economy, and students were expected to take on the financial burden of funding that education in the interest of their own future career and financial success.
This led to not only the proliferation of student loans (which quickly shifted from federal to privatized) and student debt, but also the emphasized importance of ROI we see in the higher education landscape today.
So how can families identify colleges with higher ROI?
Look for schools with lower tuition, local or high-demand industry ties, strong alumni networks, internship and career training programs, and other key academic and career resources that can propel your student's career after graduation. Net price calculators can also help families gain an approximate understanding of a particular school’s actual price (including housing and dining expenses, textbook expenses, and typical living expenses), rather than looking only at tuition.
Examples of schools with high ROI:
Georgia Institute of Technology
Public tech giant university that frequently outranks the Ivies for ROI in engineering and tech
Highest ROI of all public schools
Ranked #1 for career placement by the Princeton Review, indicating that graduates are in high demand by employers
Graduates have an average starting salary of $93,704 (as of 2025)
Top-tier career/salary outcomes at a fraction of the private school cost of attendance ($30,928 per year for in-state students; $55,314 per year for out-of-state students)
Northeastern University
Home of renowned co-op program, in which students gain months of full-time professional work experience before they graduate
Partnered with over 3,800 global employer companies for its co-op program
96% employment or graduate school rate within nine months of graduation
Mid-career median salary of $134,600
Ranks alongside elite private research universities like Johns Hopkins and USC in long-term earnings
Colorado School of Mines
Specialized public university with a focus in STEM
Ranks #3 in the country’s public universities for 40-year ROI
Provides its students with a direct path to high-paying careers in energy, aerospace, engineering, and more
Graduates often see starting salaries that rival the top 1% of all U.S. colleges
97% employment rate within one year of graduation
20-year net ROI estimated over $1 million
Carleton College
Top-ranked liberal arts college and a "Little Ivy"
99% of recent graduates are employed, in graduate or professional school, or completing a fellowship
Incredibly-high career placement rate after graduation, including in fields like computer science and economics
Mid-career median salary of $146,100
Top 10 producer of PhDs in STEM fields among liberal arts colleges
82% medical school acceptance rate
87% law school acceptance rate
Understanding ROI is the difference between graduating with a mountain of debt and graduating with a launchpad for your future. ROI is also specific to each individual student, depending on major, location, and financial aid package.
What does ROI sometimes miss?
However, while ROI can be important to consider, it is far from the most reliable metric of the financial value of a college degree.
For example, ROI does not reliably take into account whether students plan to pursue postgraduate education after college, such as law school, medical school, or a master’s degree. College ROI often does not distinguish between the median mid-career salary of students with bachelor’s degrees and that of students who then pursue further education.
Also, ROI is typically gauged using the numbers from a school as a whole, but specific college majors can produce varying ROI results, even within the same institution. Some college majors, such as philosophy or linguistics, can lend themselves to a wider set of potential careers with varying average salaries. Other majors, such as computer science, typically funnel into a smaller number of specialized careers, which can make resulting salaries dependent on the current trajectory of one or two industries—industries that can easily be on the rise or on a downswing.
Modern ROI calculations may or may not also filter out data from students who drop out of school, which can result in drastically different numbers. Unemployment in specific industries is also not well-captured in ROI.
These caveats can all make it hard to gauge the true ROI of a particular college off their overall graduate salary numbers alone. This makes it even more critical for students and families researching potential colleges to do their research, dig deep into what exactly their student’s goals are, and figure out which colleges have the specific resources to aid their students in that pursuit.
Ensure your student's degree works as hard as they do.
Don't leave what could be your student's biggest financial decision to chance! Schedule a free consultation with us today to walk through your list and ensure you're targeting schools that offer the best return for your student's specific goals.